| The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |

A group of ministers from Commonwealth countries has called on the Zimbabwean authorities to look into allegations of human rights violations.
|
Zimbabwe agreed at Abuja |
|
No further occupations of white-owned farms
To restore the rule of law to the process of land reform
To the principle of freedom of expression
To take firm action against violence and
intimidation |
Under the terms of that agreement, Zimbabwe promised to end violent invasions of white-owned land, while Britain pledged to help fund a peaceful redistribution of land.
The Commonwealth ministers were deeply divided on what to say at the end of their visit, and eventually came up with a weak declaration.
The ministers, accompanied by the Commonwealth Secretary General, Don McKinnon, had spoken to President Robert Mugabe and opposition politicians.
![]() White farmers say land invasions are
continuing |
The Canadian Secretary of State for Africa, David Kilgour, who was openly critical of the Zimbabwean authorities, told the BBC that his government had almost abandoned the exercise.
He had wanted a greater emphasis on what he perceives as the breakdown of law and order in Zimbabwe. Britain supported his position.
But in public, all parties remain committed to the Abuja agreement on peaceful land reform.
The United Nations Development Programme is now charged with supervising its implementation. A UNDP team is expected in Zimbabwe next month.
From The Zimbabwe Independent, 26 October
Commonwealth team rejects attempt to restrict enquiry
The visiting Commonwealth team of ministers yesterday foiled an official attempt to restrict the scope of their inquiry by foisting on them groups aligned to government while excluding genuine civic organisations. Diplomatic sources said government tried to limit those seeing the team, led by Nigerian Foreign minister Sule Olamido, to six groups. These were the Council of Chiefs, Zimbabwe Farmers Union, Indigenous Commercial Farmers Union, Zimbabwe Joint Resettlement Initiative, Commercial Farmers Union, and the parliamentary select committee on land. But the visitors, here to follow up progress on the Abuja accord, protested that they did not want to be restricted to the government list and would be happy to see any civil society group that was prepared to meet them.
"The government is trying to whitewash this," a Commonwealth diplomat said. "This is not a group of gullible people. They want to be fully informed by all sectors of Zimbabwean society and have therefore rejected this rather one-sided list." Diplomats were surprised when NGOs they had suggested did not find their way onto the list. The opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), which was not on the original official list, is expected to meet the team today. MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai and his foreign affairs spokesman, Tendai Biti will make their presentations.
Opening their meeting yesterday Foreign Affairs minister Stan Mudenge attempted to set the agenda for the team which includes ministers from Britain, Australia, Canada, South Africa, Nigeria, Jamaica, and Kenya. He claimed the team was here to "reconcile differences between Zimbabwe and the United Kingdom" and facilitate the implementation of land reform. Despite energetic attempts by government to limit the Commonwealth’s focus to land, the club wants to look at issues of governance and compliance with the Harare Declaration, as set out in the Abuja agreement. The visiting group, which includes Commonwealth secretary-general Don McKinnon, kicked off its schedule yesterday morning by meeting President Mugabe and his two deputies, Simon Muzenda and Joseph Msika, at State House. After that it moved to a local hotel where it heard testimony from civic groups and government supporters.
Mudenge opened the session by making a number of claims to show government was complying with the Abuja accord. "You may be aware that, as our contribution to the success of the initiative, we delisted some 581 farms that did not meet our criteria just before Abuja," he said. "Since Abuja, we have delisted a further 20 such farms. This information was published in the Government Gazette of September 28. Immediately following Abuja, I triggered the process of consultation between Zimbabwe and the UNDP through calls I made to the UN secretary-general (Kofi Annan) and Jack Straw (British foreign secretary)," Mudenge said. "Subsequently, Mark Malloch Brown, the administrator of the UNDP, wrote to me. I have since replied, and we expect a UNDP technical team around the 29th of this month." UNDP officials yesterday said they expected the team to assess the land reform situation in Zimbabwe from November 5.
Mudenge also said cabinet as well as the ruling Zanu PF met after Abuja to consider and adopt the agreement. He said committees were set up to implement the accord. The Abuja accord, signed in the Nigerian capital on September 6, demanded Harare should address specific issues: end fresh land invasions, remove illegal occupiers, restore the rule of law, stop violence, uphold human rights and democratic values, and embark on a just and fair land reform programme. Civic organisations, including the CFU, have said new land occupations, violence, and other forms of violations of the Abuja agreement persisted despite government claims of compliance.
From The Daily Telegraph (UK), 27 October
Mugabe behind farm violence, diplomats told
An attempt by President Robert Mugabe's government to stage-manage a Commonwealth tour of Zimbabwe's farms backfired yesterday when delegates heard graphic accounts of state-sponsored violence across the once buoyant rural sector. At one property the delegates heard first hand how white-owned farms continued to be invaded by so-called war veterans loyal to Mr Mugabe after the accord signed in Abuja last month when Zimbabwe agreed to stop all invasions. A visit to a second farm, which the government had thought would project a favourable image, was marred by accusations that the farmer had been threatened by government officials not to tell the truth about how he lost his land.
At one point angry words were exchanged between government minders and a Canadian member of the delegation after he was blocked from talking to a group of white farmers not on the official tour itinerary. Diplomats said there was "unease" and "clear polarisation" between Zimbabwean officials and white farmers. "We know what the Zimbabwean government wanted them to hear but they were left in no doubt the Abuja agreement had been violated," one Western diplomat said. The delegation delayed its departure from Zimbabwe by 12 hours until this morning after lengthy postponements in meetings called with lawyers, churchmen, journalists and other representatives of civil society. It is expected that a final communiqué from the group will condemn Zimbabwe for failing to live up to the undertakings made in Abuja.
But Western diplomats said it would be counter-productive to declare the Abuja agreement completely dead as it served the useful diplomatic purpose of at least keeping international attention focused on Zimbabwe. At the first farm visited by the delegation it was alleged that the owner, Jannie Erasmus, had been instructed to say that he had voluntarily conceded his property for resettlement. Instead he told of 18 months of horror and trauma suffered by himself, his workers, and his herd of pedigree cattle. Mr Erasmus's farm had been chosen for the Commonwealth visit because he had decided that he could no longer continue farming. A local government official visited him the day before the visit and warned him not to speak out, according to another farmer, Japie Jackson.
The seven Commonwealth ministers and officials flew to Bita Farm to hear first hand evidence of contraventions of the agreement. Pete Bibby, 36, said he had conceded one of his two farms for resettlement, and wanted to continue growing crops with his father John, 70, on Bita. He told the group that a week after the agreement was hailed as a way forward on the Zimbabwe crisis, about 50 government supporters arrived on the farm at night and became involved in a fight with his workers and peasant farmers. In the confrontation, two government supporters fell off their vehicle and were run over, allegedly by their comrades. His father, who was not present at the time of the incident, was arrested and charged with murder and incitement to violence. More than 60 farm workers were also arrested, and are awaiting trial. The chairman of the delegation, Sule Lamido, Nigeria's foreign minister, wanted to hear the views of the farm workers at Bita. But none was available to be asked. European Union foreign ministers will meet on Monday to discuss Zimbabwe. The issue of possible EU sanctions is expected to top the agenda.
From The Zimbabwe Independent, 26 October
Zanu PF arms war vets, reignites terror
The ruling Zanu PF party, in cahoots with war veterans, has launched a reign of terror in the Midlands that has witnessed the closure of schools with teachers fleeing for their lives. Scores of armed war veterans were busy this week conducting rallies at schools and business centres in the province. School children have been abducted and forced to attend the rallies, missing lessons while the "O" and "A" level end-of-year examinations are in progress. Some of the war veterans are reported to have claimed that they left school to join the liberation struggle and there was nothing special about school children leaving school to attend their rallies. Gabriel Shumba, a human rights lawyer working with the Amani Trust - a body that attends to victims of political violence - told the Independent that he had handled several cases of political beatings, the majority being secondary school teachers. Many had now deserted their schools and gone into nearby Gweru and Zvishavane for refuge. In Mberengwa, Zanu PF has launched a crackdown on suspected Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) supporters. Secondary school teachers and students have of late been forced to attend rallies and chant Zanu PF slogans with the most affected areas being Vutika, Mupandashango, Danga, Mataga, Mnene, Vutsanana and Rengwe.
A teacher who declined to be named told the Independent that the notorious architect of terror in Mberengwa, Biggie Chitoro’s colleagues were continuing where Chitoro left off. Some of his armed henchmen include Divine Chitoro, his younger brother, and Nyasha Koke. Koke hails from Rengwe and is still on bail after being charged with being an accomplice in political violence and murder. "They (Koke and Chitoro) are armed and the police are not doing anything," the teacher said. "Many teachers have fled the on-going violence and there are no normal lessons going on at Vutika secondary school," he said. Teachers identified as V Moyo, Marufu, Gumbo, and headmaster Hove, whose property was burnt last year by war veterans, have left the school. At the school a war veteran and teacher, Walter Mucheregwa, was singled out as terrorising MDC supporters and issuing political threats of victimisation to fellow teachers he suspected had links with the MDC. "Mucheregwa is a war veteran and targets any teacher suspected to have links with the MDC," the teacher said. The teacher added that Zanu PF supporters thought of Chitoro as a hero and some youths now wanted to take over from where he left off. "A Zanu PF councillor in Rengwe - identified only as Mhike - was allegedly masterminding the terror in Mberengwa.
In Gokwe in the Midlands, the situation had reportedly got out of hand. Seven schools have been closed while scores of teachers have fled. Shumba said he had received cases of six teachers that were squatting in Gweru after having abandoned their belongings at their respective schools fleeing violence. The affected schools are Tenda secondary, Zhomba primary and two other schools in Sanyati, near Kadoma. "War veterans are abducting school children and taking them to their bases around Gokwe," Shumba said. "As we speak seven schools have been closed. We have interviewed some of the victims who confessed that the number of students attending lessons has declined. Students are being taught politics of land and Zanu PF," he said. Shumba said the perpetrators of violence were armed and the police were not doing anything about it. "What is the logic behind giving a war veteran, whose life is not under threat from anyone, and a village headman a firearm?" he asked. "Where did they get the firearm licences from? It is just strange and it now appears that the police are aiding and abetting the crisis situation in Gokwe," he said. One of the headmen in Gokwe, Mabasa Munotengwa, was reportedly armed and terrorising people. "Any reasonable person in a civilised country would find it nauseating that politicians would stoop so low," Shumba said. "That some people are being allowed to unleash such untold suffering amongst innocent civilians is just politically wrong and immoral. They are raping some of the school children. They ask them to chant Zanu PF slogans. What kind of a society is it that condones such activities?" Shumba said. Police spokesperson Assistant Commissioner Wayne Bvudzijena said he was "busy" and was going to attend to the Independent inquiries later.
From The Independent (UK), 27 October
Farm invasions have not stopped, ministers told
Harare - Baroness Amos and other Commonwealth ministers heard first-hand accounts of illegal farm invasions and intimidation by government supporters as they toured Zimbabwean farmland on a mission aimed at ensuring that President Robert Mugabe will comply with a plan to end the land crisis. At Mr Mugabe's invitation, the ministers were flown to southern Masvingo province to meet settlers who took up plots on farms under the "fast-track resettlement programme" - the name the government has given to what others see as state-sponsored farm invasions. They then returned to Harare to hold discussions with representatives of civil society, including war veteran supporters of Mr Mugabe, the main opposition, and journalists.
But a white farmer who spoke for the community of Hwedza, 200km south-east of Harare, accused the government of failing to meet commitments agreed in the Nigerian capital, Abuja, in September. Japie Jackson told the ministers at Bath Farm that the mainly white commercial farmers had been warned not to tell the truth about the situation, otherwise there would be "severe consequences". Under the pact, the government agreed to stop landless blacks taking over white-owned farms, and Britain pledged to help fund a fair and just land reform programme. But according to the Commercial Farmers Union, which groups 4,500 farmers, at least 680 farms have been occupied since the Abuja agreement. Of these, 200-300 were new invasions, while the rest were on occupied farms where new settlers joined those already there.
Mr Jackson said that needy people were not being given land. Instead, he claimed, it was being earmarked for army officers, district administrators, policemen and "others who are in a position to influence next year's vote". The Commonwealth team, which winds up its mission today, also heard complaints from journalists' representatives, who protested against harassment by so-called war veterans as they attempted to cover events. They also complained of the government's "sustained campaign to muzzle the media". About 100 private news vendors have been detained and released as part of the systematic harassment campaign, effectively preventing them from selling their newspapers over the past three weeks. The latest example was the arrest of the board of the Daily News, Zimbabwe's leading independent newspaper, as the Commonwealth team were meeting with President Mugabe on Thursday.
No details of that meeting have been made public, but diplomats said that Mr Mugabe told the ministers that he was committed to the deal to end the violent invasions of the white-owned farms, which began in February last year. The Zimbabwean leader also warned Western governments that they had to do their part to end the 20-month-old standoff, according to the diplomats. War veterans' representatives who met with the Commonwealth ministers yesterday warned Britain that they would "not allow Britain to manipulate Abuja" in the way that the UK had allegedly done with the Lancaster House agreement that brought Zimbabwean independence. Led by the Nigerian Foreign Minister, Sule Lamido, the mission to Harare includes the Commonwealth Secretary-General Don McKinnon, Britain's Baroness Valerie Amos, and representatives from Kenya, South Africa, Canada and Australia. The ministers are expected to set a timetable for the full implementation of the Abuja pact. The visit came as the European Union is moving closer to applying sanctions against Zimbabwe over its human rights record and its failure to end the land chaos.
From BBC News, 26 October
Food shortages in Zimbabwe shops
Zimbabwe is facing serious food shortages due to price controls imposed earlier this month by the government in a bid to control runaway inflation. According to reports in the independent Zimbabwean media, price caps on basic foodstuffs have forced many producers to operate at a loss, leaving them with no choice but to go out of business. The baking industry, which has been losing an estimated $33,000 a day, has been hit particularly hard. Basic goods including bread, wheat, maize, cooking oil and soap are reported to be becoming increasingly scarce as a result, with rationing now in force in many areas.
The Zimbabwean Government imposed the price caps on 10 October, citing the need to bring the country's inflation rate under control, which is currently running at over 70% a year. The country's soaring inflation stems from the weakness of the Zimbabwean dollar and its heavy reliance on imported fuel, priced in US dollars. A slump in the world price of metals and agricultural commodities, the country's principal exports, has deprived Zimbabwean importers of hard currency. Grain shortages caused by the government's policy of seizing white-owned farms have also fuelled a sharp increase in food prices.
Some observers in the Zimbabwean capital, Harare, believe that the price controls are a populist measure designed to shore up electoral support for Mr Mugabe's government ahead of presidential elections next year. "The government wants to be sure that it can rely on the urban vote, but the policy is backfiring already. We are heading into serious shortages, and the people are angry," said one local source. Zimbabwe is due to hold presidential elections by April 2002, but no firm date has yet been set.
From the BBC
Zimbabwe double-bill
For those with access to the BBC Knowledge TV channel, there will be a two-hour long double-bill on Zimbabwe tonight, Saturday 27 October.
20:00 Langan In Zimbabwe - Journalist Sean Langan ventures into Zimbabwe in the wake of the recent land disputes and ahead of the by elections to find out how the black community views the conflict.
21:00 Inside The Mind Of Mugabe - Allan Little and a panel of experts try to unravel the complex mind of Zimbabwe's president. They attempt to identify what caused the descent from independence champion to dictator.